A Light Hand

Indian · Bite / Side / Appetizer

Machh'er Chop

Kolkata's fish croquette: a fiery, sweet-sour mash of fish and onion, crumbed and deep-fried.

314kcal per serving, as written

The biggest sources are oil for deep-frying (31%) and breadcrumbs (17%). Set your target below and we'll rescale it.

  • Kolkata, Bengal, East India
  • 1 h 30 min
  • Non-Vegetarian
  • hot

Adapted from a recipe by Bong Eats, Bong Eats (bongeats.com)

Source and data

Adapted from “Machh'er Chop” by Bong Eats (Bong Eats (bongeats.com)), accessed 2026-11-21. We use this published recipe as a reference for the dish's ingredients, proportions and technique. The method on this page is written by A Light Hand, and the original author hasn't reviewed or endorsed this adaptation. Nutrition figures are estimates, and the calorie-adjusted versions haven't been kitchen-tested. Published servings: 12 chops.

Something off with this recipe? Tell us

How we sourced and calculated this

Region: Kolkata, Bengal, East India (as described by the recipe source).

How we read this recipe

  • The source says Bengali homes make it from rui or katla and Kolkata cabins from bhetki trimmings; it uses aar (a large catfish). We count rohu (IFCT 2017).
  • Each of the 12 chops is one serving. The source lists 257 kcal per chop; our figure (about 310) is higher, mostly from the breading and absorbed oil we estimate.
  • The breading (flour, egg, crumbs) has no amounts in the source; we count 2 eggs, ½ cup flour and 1½ cups crumbs for 12 chops (estimate). All the coating is counted, though some is always left on the plate, so the real figure is a little lower.
  • Aamchur, MSG-free bhaja moshla and gorom moshla have no separate composition data; the two masalas are counted as garam masala and the aamchur isn't counted.
  • The oil for deep-frying isn't eaten in full. We count what the food absorbs, estimated at 10% of the wet batter weight (anchored to USDA's home-prepared falafel); it's marked as an estimate on the ingredient.

Estimated weights

  • Green chilies, slit: 2.5 × 5 g per green chili (small Indian green chili) (estimate).
  • Garam masala: Bhaja moshla (roasted cumin, coriander and chilli) is counted as garam masala.
  • Flour (maida), for dredging: No amount in the source; ½ cup for 12 chops (estimate).
  • Eggs, beaten (for coating): No amount in the source; 2 eggs for 12 chops (estimate).
  • Breadcrumbs: No amount in the source; 1½ cups for 12 chops (estimate).
  • Oil for deep-frying (amount absorbed): Oil absorbed while deep-frying, estimated at 10% of the wet batter weight (about 1327 g here, soaked dal counted at twice its dry weight). USDA's home-prepared falafel (FDC 172455), a deep-fried soaked-legume batter like a vada, is 17.8 g fat per 100 g against about 4 g in the raw mix, and loses about a third of its weight as water in the fryer: roughly 10 g of oil absorbed per 100 g of wet batter. Real uptake varies with oil temperature and batter moisture.

Data notes

  • Rohu IFCT 2017, code S006. From the Indian Food Composition Tables 2017 (National Institute of Nutrition, Hyderabad), read from the ifct2017 data package's transcription. IFCT reports energy in kJ; converted at 4.184 kJ per kcal. Check against the printed tables before commercial use.
  • Spices, cumin seed USDA FDC 170923, SR Legacy. Also used for ground cumin. USDA's teaspoon weight is for whole seed.
  • Spices, coriander seed USDA FDC 170922, SR Legacy. Used for coriander powder.
  • Spices, pepper, red or cayenne USDA FDC 170932, SR Legacy. Proxy for Kashmiri red chili powder, which has no USDA entry. Both are ground dried Capsicum; heat differs, energy is assumed similar.
  • GARAM MASALA (Sands Impex) USDA FDC 2525305, Branded. Spice blends vary by brand; SR Legacy has no garam masala entry.
  • Oil, canola USDA FDC 172336, SR Legacy. Used for recipes that call for unspecified neutral cooking oil.

Nutrition reference: USDA FoodData Central (https://fdc.nal.usda.gov) and the Indian Food Composition Tables 2017 (National Institute of Nutrition, Hyderabad), retrieved 2026-11-21. Cooking losses (oil left in the pan, marinade left in the bowl) are not subtracted, so these estimates lean high. Full method and every food record.

More like this

All seafood →